Yes: Elden Ring can be a good first Soulslike, with more escape valves than FromSoftware's other Soulslikes, but it is a weaker teacher than Dark Souls.
Summons, co-op, an open world you can ride away into and short run-backs to bosses let a newcomer lower the difficulty themselves. The trade-off, in our scoring, is that it expects most core skills rather than teaching them. Here's who should start with it, who should begin with Dark Souls Remastered or Hollow Knight instead, and how to get the most from Elden Ring if it's your first.
▶ Interactive · Is Elden Ring a good first Soulslike?
Yes, Elden Ring can be your first Soulslike, and for many people it's the friendliest door in. It hands you more ways around a wall than any other FromSoftware Soulslike: summoned helpers, an open world you can ride away into, and the freedom to level up and come back. The catch is that it's a weaker teacher. It asks for almost every core skill but rarely forces you to learn them in order, so some players finish it leaning on those helpers rather than having learned the fundamentals.
A Soulslike is an action game built like FromSoftware's Dark Souls: deliberate combat, bosses you learn by heart, and deaths that cost you progress. Elden Ring (FromSoftware, 2022) is the biggest of them. It's on PlayStation, Xbox and PC, and the Tarnished Edition, which bundles the Shadow of the Erdtree expansion, came to Nintendo Switch 2 in August 2026.
The shape of the difficulty
"Is it too hard?" is the wrong question, because difficulty isn't one number. We describe it by five sources: execution (timing and precision), systems (stats and builds), consequence (what failing costs you), endurance (length and attrition) and competition (other people). In our scoring, Elden Ring asks for the most execution of the three games below and has the deepest build system, but its failures cost a little less than Dark Souls', because help is never far away.
The three games share a subgenre and the same kind of hard, which is what makes comparing them fair. Hollow Knight is 2D and sits just beside the genre, but trains the same boss-learning loop.
The case for starting with Elden Ring
Elden Ring has no difficulty setting, but it has more escape valves than any FromSoftware game before it, and each one lets you lower the difficulty yourself without anyone knowing:
Spirit Ashes. Once you have the Spirit Calling Bell, you can summon computer-controlled allies in many boss fights.
Co-op. If you play online, you can call other players into your world to help with a boss.
The open world. Stuck on a boss? Ride off on Torrent, your spectral horse, level up elsewhere and return stronger.
Short run-backs. Stakes of Marika, respawn points placed near many boss arenas, mean a failed attempt rarely costs a long walk back.
Together these lower the consequence source sharply. That matters for a newcomer, who will fail a lot while learning: when each failure costs less, you get more attempts before frustration sets in.
The case against: it demands more than it teaches
Here's the argument, with the evidence in the "Skills" view above. We tag seven skills that carry across the genre: managing a stamina bar, dodging with i-frames (the brief invincibility during a roll), parrying, reading a boss's patterns, healing only when it's safe, memorising layouts, and building a character. In our tagging, Dark Souls teaches five of them; Elden Ring teaches one and simply expects most of the rest. Its open early game lets you route around the lessons that Dark Souls's narrower opening forces on you, so gaps can stay hidden until a late boss tests everything at once.
The fair counter-view: a teacher you quit isn't teaching anything. If Elden Ring's escape valves keep you playing long enough, the skills sink in anyway, just later and less tidily. If you'd only give the genre one chance, the game you'll stick with beats the game that teaches best. All three games also reward a patient tempo; that's a habit, not a skill, and faster Soulslikes such as Bloodborne will ask you to unlearn it.
Who should start with Elden Ring
Start with it if you like exploring, you'd rather go somewhere else than retry a boss twenty times, and you're happy to use summons without feeling it doesn't count. It does count.
Start somewhere else if you want to really learn the genre, or open worlds make you feel lost. Dark Souls Remastered (PlayStation 4, Xbox One, PC and Switch) is the stronger teacher: fewer ways around a problem, so you learn stamina, rolling and healing because you have to. If even that sounds like a lot, Hollow Knight is the gentlest ramp: the same learn-the-boss loop in 2D, with no stamina bar to manage. Our piece on whether to play Hollow Knight before Silksong covers where that leads.
If you do start with Elden Ring
Use Spirit Ashes on the first boss that stops you, and watch the boss while it's busy: free pattern-reading practice.
Treat healing as a committed action. Drinking takes time and can be punished; heal after a boss's combo ends, not in the middle of it.
When a boss feels impossible, leave. Coming back ten levels later isn't cheating; it's the design.
Next step: if you want the freedom, start Elden Ring and use every helper it offers; if you want the foundations, play Dark Souls Remastered first and save Elden Ring as your second game, where it's a clean step up.
Quick answers
Is Elden Ring too hard for a beginner?
It's demanding, but summons, co-op and the open world let beginners lower the difficulty themselves.
Does Elden Ring have an easy mode?
No, there's no difficulty setting; Spirit Ashes and levelling up do that job instead.
Should I play Dark Souls before Elden Ring?
Not required, but Dark Souls teaches the fundamentals more directly, which makes Elden Ring a smoother second game.
Loadout · gear used
Affiliate links, marked sponsored. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Examples that match this guide, not tested reviews. Prices checked 19 Nov; every shop and live prices are on each product page.
The game this guide weighs up: more escape valves than any other FromSoftware Soulslike, from Spirit Ash summons to an open world you can ride away into. This edition bundles the Shadow of the Erdtree expansion.
The stronger teacher: fewer ways around a problem, so stamina, rolling and healing get learned because they have to be. Makes Elden Ring a clean second game.